Logo image
Back
Teaching ethics
Book chapter

Teaching ethics

V. Dawson, R. Lock, N.W. Brickhouse and J. Crosthwaite
Dilemmas of Science Teaching: Perspectives on Problems of Practice, pp.175-190
Routledge as part of the Taylor and Francis group
2005
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203996294
url
Link to Published Version *Subscription may be requiredView

Abstract

As Michael Matthews has observed,‘philosophy is not far below the surface in any science classroom’ (1998, p. 995). Complex epistemological questions may emerge from even the most routine classroom treatments of the scientific method. What counts as evidence in a particular lesson? What is the epistemological status of the models and analogies students are expected to reproduce in tests? Similarly, metaphysical questions separate the truth claims of western science and indigenous knowledge, and evolutionary science from creationism. In addition, many students bring to class strong views about the medical and environmental issues that they cover in science. Whenever science and social policy intersect, such ethical questions arise. As the history of Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy in the United Kingdom shows, ethical and scientific issues cannot be disentangled (United Kingdom, 2000). How soon did the scientific consensus emerge that the disease was a risk to humans? How much sooner did some suspect it? What social judgements would have been drawn if they overestimated the risk, announced it too soon, and needlessly slaughtered the British cattle herd? In a society dominated by risk (Giddens, 1999) scientists are forever caught between the possibility of panic and the fear of involvement in a cover up.

Details

Metrics

72 Record Views
Logo image