Journal article
Global urban environmental change drives adaptation in white clover
Science, Vol.375(Art. 6586), pp.1275-1281
2022
Abstract
Urbanization transforms environments in ways that alter biological evolution. We examined whether urban environmental change drives parallel evolution by sampling 110,019 white clover plants from 6169 populations in 160 cities globally. Plants were assayed for a Mendelian antiherbivore defense that also affects tolerance to abiotic stressors. Urban-rural gradients were associated with the evolution of clines in defense in 47% of cities throughout the world. Variation in the strength of clines was explained by environmental changes in drought stress and vegetation cover that varied among cities. Sequencing 2074 genomes from 26 cities revealed that the evolution of urban-rural clines was best explained by adaptive evolution, but the degree of parallel adaptation varied among cities. Our results demonstrate that urbanization leads to adaptation at a global scale.
Details
- Title
- Global urban environmental change drives adaptation in white clover
- Authors/Creators
- J.S. Santangelo (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoR.W. Ness (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoB. Cohan (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoC.R. Fitzpatrick (Author/Creator) - University of North Carolina at Chapel HillS.G. Innes (Author/Creator) - University of Louisiana at LafayetteS. Koch (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoL.S. Miles (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoS. Munim (Author/Creator) - Queen's UniversityP.R. Peres-Neto (Author/Creator) - Concordia UniversityC. Prashad (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoA.T. Tong (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoW.E. Aguirre (Author/Creator) - DePaul UniversityP.O. Akinwole (Author/Creator) - DePauw UniversityM. Alberti (Author/Creator) - Urban Design GroupJ. Álvarez (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoJ.T. Anderson (Author/Creator) - Department of Genetics, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA.J.J. Anderson (Author/Creator) - Uppsala UniversityY. Ando (Author/Creator) - Hokkaido UniversityN.R. Andrew (Author/Creator) - University of New EnglandF. Angeoletto (Author/Creator) - Universidade Federal de Minas GeraisD.N. Anstett (Author/Creator) - University of British ColumbiaJ. Anstett (Author/Creator) - University of British ColumbiaF. Aoki-Gonçalves (Author/Creator) - Instituto de EcologíaA.Z.A. Arietta (Author/Creator) - Yale UniversityM.T.K. Arroyo (Author/Creator) - University of ChileE.J. Austen (Author/Creator) - Mount Allison UniversityF. Baena-Díaz (Author/Creator) - Instituto de EcologíaC.A. Barker (Author/Creator) - University of OttawaH.A. Baylis (Author/Creator) - University of CambridgeJ.M. Beliz (Author/Creator) - University of MiamiA. Benitez-Mora (Author/Creator) - Universidad Bernardo O'HigginsD. Bickford (Author/Creator) - University of La VerneG. Biedebach (Author/Creator) - University of La VerneG.S. Blackburn (Author/Creator) - Université LavalM.M.A. Boehm (Author/Creator) - University of British ColumbiaS.P. Bonser (Author/Creator) - UNSW SydneyD. Bonte (Author/Creator) - Ghent University HospitalJ.R. Bragger (Author/Creator) - Monmouth UniversityC. Branquinho (Author/Creator) - University of LisbonK.I. Brans (Author/Creator) - University of CopenhagenJ.C. Bresciano (Author/Creator) - Massey UniversityP.D. Brom (Author/Creator) - University of Cape TownA. Bucharova (Author/Creator) - University of MünsterB. Burt (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyJ.F. Cahill (Author/Creator) - University of AlbertaK.D. Campbell (Author/Creator) - University of OttawaE.J. Carlen (Author/Creator) - Fordham UniversityD. Carmona (Author/Creator) - Universidad Autónoma de YucatánM.C. Castellanos (Author/Creator) - University of SussexG. Centenaro (Author/Creator) - Stockholm UniversityI. Chalen (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoJ.A. Chaves (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoM. Chávez-Pesqueira (Author/Creator) - Unidad de Recursos Naturales, Centro de Investigación Científica de Yucatán AC, Mérida, Yucatán, México.X-Y Chen (Author/Creator) - East China Normal UniversityA.M. Chilton (Author/Creator) - UNSW SydneyK.M. Chomiak (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyD.F. Cisneros-Heredia (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoI.K. Cisse (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyA.T. Classen (Author/Creator) - University of MichiganM.S. Comerford (Author/Creator) - Rice UniversityC.C. Fradinger (Author/Creator) - Universidad de Buenos AiresH. Corney (Author/Creator) - Saint Mary's UniversityA.J. Crawford (Author/Creator) - Universidad de Los AndesK.M. Crawford (Author/Creator) - University of HoustonM. Dahirel (Author/Creator) - Ecosystèmes, Biodiversité, EvolutionS. David (Author/Creator) - University of British ColumbiaR. De Haan (Author/Creator) - Dordt UniversityN.J. Deacon (Author/Creator) - Minneapolis CollegeC. Dean (Author/Creator) - Manchester Metropolitan UniversityE. del-Val (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoE.K. Deligiannis (Author/Creator) - Aristotle University of ThessalonikiD. Denney (Author/Creator) - Department of Genetics, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA.M.A. Dettlaff (Author/Creator) - University of AlbertaM.F. DiLeo (Author/Creator) - University of HelsinkiY-Y Ding (Author/Creator) - East China Normal UniversityM.E. Domínguez-López (Author/Creator) - Corporación Científica Ingeobosque, Medellín, Antioquia, Colombia.D.M. Dominoni (Author/Creator) - University of GlasgowS.L. Draud (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeK. Dyson (Author/Creator) - Urban Design GroupJ. Ellers (Author/Creator) - Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamC.I. Espinosa (Author/Creator) - Universidad Técnica Particular de LojaL. Essi (Author/Creator) - Universidade Federal de Santa MariaM. Falahati-Anbaran (Author/Creator) - University of TehranJ.C.F. Falcão (Author/Creator)H.T. Fargo (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoM.D.E. Fellowes (Author/Creator) - University of ReadingR.M. Fitzpatrick (Author/Creator) - Northern Arizona UniversityL.E. Flaherty (Author/Creator) - MacEwan UniversityP. J. Flood (Author/Creator) - Max Planck Institute for Plant Breeding ResearchM.F. Flores (Author/Creator) - University of ChileJ. Fornoni (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoA.G. Foster (Author/Creator) - Max Planck Institute of Molecular Plant PhysiologyC.J. Frost (Author/Creator)T.L. Fuentes (Author/Creator) - Urban Design GroupJ.R. Fulkerson (Author/Creator) - University of Alaska AnchorageE. Gagnon (Author/Creator) - Université de MonctonF. Garbsch (Author/Creator) - Max Planck Institute of Molecular Plant PhysiologyC.J. Garroway (Author/Creator) - University of ManitobaA.C. Gerstein (Author/Creator) - University of ManitobaM.M. Giasson (Author/Creator) - University of New BrunswickE.B. Girdler (Author/Creator) - Kalamazoo CollegeS. Gkelis (Author/Creator) - Aristotle University of ThessalonikiW. Godsoe (Author/Creator) - Canterbury of New ZealandA.M. Golemiec (Author/Creator) - Queen's UniversityM. Golemiec (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoC. González-Lagos (Author/Creator) - Universidad Bernardo O'HigginsA.J. Gorton (Author/Creator) - University of MinnesotaK.M. Gotanda (Author/Creator) - Brock UniversityG. Granath (Author/Creator) - Uppsala UniversityS. Greiner (Author/Creator) - Max Planck Institute of Molecular Plant PhysiologyJ.S. Griffiths (Author/Creator) - University of California, DavisF. Grilo (Author/Creator) - University of LisbonP.E. Gundel (Author/Creator) - University of TalcaB. Hamilton (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyJ.M. Hardin (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeT. He (Author/Creator) - Murdoch UniversityS.B. Heard (Author/Creator) - University of New BrunswickA.F. Henriques (Author/Creator) - University of LisbonM. Hernández-Poveda (Author/Creator) - Universidad de Los AndesM.C. Hetherington-Rauth (Author/Creator) - University of TorontoS.J. Hill (Author/Creator) - University of New EnglandD.F. Hochuli (Author/Creator) - The University of SydneyK.A. Hodgins (Author/Creator) - Monash UniversityG.R. Hood (Author/Creator) - Wayne State UniversityG.R. Hopkins (Author/Creator) - Western Oregon UniversityK.A. Hovanes (Author/Creator) - University of ArizonaA.R. Howard (Author/Creator) - Western Oregon UniversityS.C. Hubbard (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeC.N. Ibarra-Cerdeña (Author/Creator) - Centro de Investigación y de Estudios Avanzados del Instituto Politécnico NacionalC. Iñiguez-Armijos (Author/Creator) - Universidad Técnica Particular de LojaP. Jara-Arancio (Author/Creator) - Institute of Ecology and BiodiversityB.J.M. Jarrett (Author/Creator) - Lund UniversityM. Jeannot (Author/Creator) - Norwegian University of Science and TechnologyV. Jiménez-Lobato (Author/Creator) - Autonomous University of GuerreroM. Johnson (Author/Creator) - Clarkson Secondary School, Peel District School Board, Mississauga, ON, Canada.O. Johnson (Author/Creator) - Homelands Sr. Public School, Peel District School Board, Mississauga, ON, Canada.P.P. Johnson (Author/Creator) - University of Illinois ChicagoR. Johnson (Author/Creator) - Catholic Social ServicesM.P. Josephson (Author/Creator) - University of CalgaryM.C. Jung (Author/Creator) - Urban Design GroupM.G. Just (Author/Creator) - United States Department of the ArmyA. Kahilainen (Author/Creator) - University of HelsinkiO.S. Kailing (Author/Creator) - Oberlin CollegeE. Kariñho-Betancourt (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoR. Karousou (Author/Creator) - Aristotle University of ThessalonikiL.A. Kirn (Author/Creator) - Monash UniversityA. Kirschbaum (Author/Creator) - University of TübingenA-L Laine (Author/Creator) - University of ZurichJ.M. LaMontagne (Author/Creator) - DePaul UniversityC. Lampei (Author/Creator) - University of MünsterC. Lara (Author/Creator) - Universidad Católica de la Santísima ConcepciónE.L. Larson (Author/Creator) - University of DenverA. Lázaro-Lobo (Author/Creator) - Mississippi State UniversityJ.H. Le (Author/Creator) - Rutgers, The State University of New JerseyD.S. Leandro (Author/Creator) - Universidade Federal de Minas GeraisC. Lee (Author/Creator) - Monash UniversityY. Lei (Author/Creator) - Kunming Institute of BotanyC.A. León (Author/Creator) - Universidad Bernardo O'HigginsM.E. Lequerica Tamara (Author/Creator)D.C. Levesque (Author/Creator) - Laurentian UniversityW-J Liao (Author/Creator) - Beijing Normal UniversityM. Ljubotina (Author/Creator) - University of AlbertaH. Locke (Author/Creator) - University of HoustonM.T. Lockett (Author/Creator) - The University of MelbourneT.C. Longo (Author/Creator) - Monmouth UniversityJ.T. Lundholm (Author/Creator) - Saint Mary's UniversityT. MacGillavry (Author/Creator) - University of GlasgowC.R. Mackin (Author/Creator) - University of SussexA.R. Mahmoud (Author/Creator) - Washington University in St. LouisI.A. Manju (Author/Creator) - Western Oregon UniversityJ. Mariën (Author/Creator) - Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamD.N. Martínez (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoM. Martínez-Bartolomé (Author/Creator) - Auburn UniversityE.K. Meineke (Author/Creator) - University of California, DavisW. Mendoza-Arroyo (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoT. J.S. Merritt (Author/Creator) - Laurentian UniversityL.E.L. Merritt (Author/Creator) - Laurentian UniversityG. Migiani (Author/Creator) - University of GlasgowE.S. Minor (Author/Creator) - University of Illinois ChicagoN. Mitchell (Author/Creator) - University of New MexicoM. Mohammadi Bazargani (Author/Creator)A.T. Moles (Author/Creator) - UNSW SydneyJ.D. Monk (Author/Creator) - Yale UniversityC.M. Moore (Author/Creator) - Colby CollegeP.A. Morales-Morales (Author/Creator)B.T. Moyers (Author/Creator) - Colorado State UniversityM. Muñoz-Rojas (Author/Creator) - Universidad de SevillaJ. Munshi-South (Author/Creator) - Fordham UniversityS.M. Murphy (Author/Creator) - University of DenverM.M. Murúa (Author/Creator) - GEMAM. Neila (Author/Creator) - Universidad Bernardo O'HigginsO. Nikolaidis (Author/Creator) - Rutgers, The State University of New JerseyI. Njunjić (Author/Creator) - Naturalis Biodiversity CenterP. Nosko (Author/Creator) - Nipissing UniversityJ. Núñez-Farfán (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoT. Ohgushi (Author/Creator) - Kyoto UniversityK.M. Olsen (Author/Creator) - Washington University in St. LouisØ.H. Opedal (Author/Creator) - Lund UniversityC. Ornelas (Author/Creator) - University of Alaska FairbanksA.L. Parachnowitsch (Author/Creator)A.S. Paratore (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyA.M. Parody-Merino (Author/Creator) - Massey UniversityJ. Paule (Author/Creator) - Senckenberg Research Institute and Natural History Museum Frankfurt/MO.S. Paulo (Author/Creator) - University of LisbonJ.C. Pena (Author/Creator) - Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp)V.W. Pfeiffer (Author/Creator) - University of Wisconsin–MadisonP. Pinho (Author/Creator) - University of LisbonA. Piot (Author/Creator) - Université LavalI.M. Porth (Author/Creator) - Université LavalN. Poulos (Author/Creator) - California State University, NorthridgeA. Puentes (Author/Creator) - Swedish University of Agricultural SciencesJ. Qu (Author/Creator) - Ghent University HospitalE. Quintero-Vallejo (Author/Creator) - Clínica CESS.M. Raciti (Author/Creator) - Long Island UniversityJ.A.M. Raeymaekers (Author/Creator) - Nord UniversityK.M. Raveala (Author/Creator) - University of HelsinkiD.J. Rennison (Author/Creator) - University of California San DiegoM.C. Ribeiro (Author/Creator) - Universidade Estadual Paulista (Unesp)J.L. Richardson (Author/Creator) - University of RichmondG. Rivas-Torres (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoB. J. Rivera (Author/Creator) - Kalamazoo CollegeA.B. Roddy (Author/Creator) - Florida International UniversityE. Rodriguez-Muñoz (Author/Creator) - Universidad de Los AndesJ.R. Román (Author/Creator) - University of AlmeríaL.S. Rossi (Author/Creator) - Nipissing UniversityJ.K. Rowntree (Author/Creator) - Manchester Metropolitan UniversityT.J. Ryan (Author/Creator) - Butler UniversityS. Salinas (Author/Creator) - Kalamazoo CollegeN.J. Sanders (Author/Creator) - University of MichiganL.Y. Santiago-Rosario (Author/Creator) - Louisiana State UniversityA.M. Savage (Author/Creator) - Rutgers, The State University of New JerseyJ.F. Scheepens (Author/Creator) - Goethe University FrankfurtM. Schilthuizen (Author/Creator) - Leiden UniversityA.C. Schneider (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeT. Scholier (Author/Creator) - University of JyväskyläJ.L. Scott (Author/Creator) - University of LouisvilleS.A. Shaheed (Author/Creator) - Monmouth UniversityR.P. Shefferson (Author/Creator) - The University of TokyoC.A. Shepard (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeJ.A. Shykoff (Author/Creator) - Ecologie, Société, EvolutionG. Silveira (Author/Creator) - Providence CollegeA.D. Smith (Author/Creator) - University of Illinois ChicagoL. Solis-Gabriel (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoA. Soro (Author/Creator) - Martin Luther University Halle-WittenbergK.V. Spellman (Author/Creator) - University of Alaska FairbanksK.S. Whitney (Author/Creator) - Rochester Institute of TechnologyI. Starke-Ottich (Author/Creator) - Senckenberg Research Institute and Natural History Museum Frankfurt/MJ.G. Stephan (Author/Creator) - Swedish University of Agricultural SciencesJ.D. Stephens (Author/Creator) - Westfield State UniversityJ. Szulc (Author/Creator) - University of WarsawM. Szulkin (Author/Creator) - University of WarsawA.J.M. Tack (Author/Creator) - Stockholm UniversityÍ. Tamburrino (Author/Creator) - University of ChileT.D. Tate (Author/Creator) - Western Oregon UniversityE. Tergemina (Author/Creator) - Max Planck Institute for Plant Breeding ResearchP. Theodorou (Author/Creator) - Martin Luther University Halle-WittenbergK.A. Thompson (Author/Creator) - Stanford UniversityC.G. Threlfall (Author/Creator) - The University of SydneyR.M. Tinghitella (Author/Creator)L. Toledo-Chelala (Author/Creator) - Universidad Nacional Autónoma de MéxicoX. Tong (Author/Creator) - East China Normal UniversityL. Uroy (Author/Creator) - Ecosystèmes, Biodiversité, EvolutionS. Utsumi (Author/Creator) - Hokkaido UniversityM.L. Vandegehuchte (Author/Creator) - Ghent University HospitalA. VanWallendael (Author/Creator) - Michigan State UniversityP.M. Vidal (Author/Creator) - University of ChileS.M. Wadgymar (Author/Creator) - Davidson CollegeA-Y Wang (Author/Creator) - Beijing Normal UniversityN. Wang (Author/Creator) - Huazhong Agricultural UniversityM.L. Warbrick (Author/Creator) - Nipissing UniversityK.D. Whitney (Author/Creator) - University of New MexicoM. Wiesmeier (Author/Creator) - Technical University of MunichJ.T. Wiles (Author/Creator) - Hendrix CollegeJ. Wu (Author/Creator) - Kunming Institute of BotanyZ.A. Xirocostas (Author/Creator) - UNSW SydneyZ. Yan (Author/Creator) - Huazhong Agricultural UniversityJ. Yao (Author/Creator) - Lanzhou UniversityJ.B. Yoder (Author/Creator) - California State University, NorthridgeO. Yoshida (Author/Creator) - Saint Mary's UniversityJ. Zhang (Author/Creator) - Kunming Institute of BotanyZ. Zhao (Author/Creator) - Lanzhou UniversityC.D. Ziter (Author/Creator) - Concordia UniversityM.P. Zuellig (Author/Creator) - University of BernR.A. Zufall (Author/Creator) - University of HoustonJ.E. Zurita (Author/Creator) - Universidad San Francisco de QuitoS.E. Zytynska (Author/Creator) - University of LiverpoolM.T.J. Johnson (Author/Creator) - University of Toronto
- Publication Details
- Science, Vol.375(Art. 6586), pp.1275-1281
- Publisher
- American Association for the Advancement of Science
- Identifiers
- 991005546015707891
- Copyright
- © 2022 American Association for the Advancement of Science.
- Murdoch Affiliation
- School of Agricultural Sciences
- Language
- English
- Resource Type
- Journal article
Metrics
40 Record Views
InCites Highlights
These are selected metrics from InCites Benchmarking & Analytics tool, related to this output
Highly Cited Paper
- Collaboration types
- Domestic collaboration
- International collaboration
- Citation topics
- 3 Agriculture, Environment & Ecology
- 3.180 Microbial Biotechnology
- 3.180.1812 Cyanide Biodegradation
- Web Of Science research areas
- Ecology
- ESI research areas
- Environment/Ecology