Logo image
Is there a need for more certainty in discretionary decision making in Australian family property law?
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Is there a need for more certainty in discretionary decision making in Australian family property law?

L. Young and J. Goodie
Australian Journal of Family Law, Vol.32(1), pp.162-188
2018
pdf
discretionary decision-making.pdfDownloadView
Published (Version of Record) Open Access

Abstract

As family law in Australia is under consideration by the Australian Law Reform Commission, it is an opportune time to consider whether the family property regime is in need of reform, in particular to provide more certainty. This article explores, and details, the courts’ power to circumscribe the exercise of discretion in this area by making legitimate guidelines and binding rules. The article argues that insufficient attention has historically been paid to this power, resulting in a lack of clarity as to the status of statements of legal principle. The article concludes that this, alone, does not justify wholesale property law reform. It supports targeted, limited, legislative reform and greater focus by the judiciary on the classification of statements of principle.

Details

Metrics

625 File views/ downloads
354 Record Views
Logo image