Journal article
Predicting disease progression in multiple sclerosis with clinically accessible information and technology
Journal of neurology, Vol.273(5), 281
2026
PMID: 42002655
Abstract
Background
Predicting disease progression at the individual level is essential for personalized medicine. We previously developed machine-learning tools to estimate 5-year progression risk in people with multiple sclerosis (PwMS). Such models should account for disease-modifying therapy (DMT) and objective outcome definitions.
Methods
In a retrospective multicenter case–control study, we evaluated adults with relapsing–remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) at baseline. Using machine-learning, we developed two complementary tools for individualized 5-year risk estimation: DAAE-M, optimized for transparency, software-neutral use, and mitigation of indication bias, and ELIE, optimized for dynamic landmark-based modeling, complex treatment histories, and mitigation of immortal-time bias. Disease progression was defined using both a clinical outcome (RRMS-to-progressive MS) and an objective outcome (late-stage confirmed progression independent of relapse activity).
Results
Among 34,510 people with RRMS (72.6% female, mean age = 37.1, mean disease duration = 5.8), 9.8% and 21% met clinical and objective progression criteria, respectively, over five years. Both models demonstrated good calibration across risk-groups (Brier scores 0.06–0.16). DAAE-M provided patient-level risk estimates with monotonic risk escalation across risk-groups for clinical (3.1%/11.2%/22.6%/33.0%) and objective (8.4%/14.5%/23.3%/38.8%) progression. For DAAE-M, high-efficacy DMT was associated with approximately half the progression risk compared with low-efficacy DMT (risk-ratios: 0.42–0.59; p < 0.01). ELIE also showed good calibration across risk deciles with increasing incidence for both clinical (0.3%/1.2%/1.7%/2.5%/3.7%/5.5%/7.2%/10.2%/14.3%/21.5%) and objective (0.9%/1.6%/2.5%/4.0%/5.8%/7.8%/10.2%/15.3%/20.9%/32.5%) outcomes.
Conclusion
We developed two well-calibrated machine-learning-based tools for individualized 5-year prediction of clinically- and objectively-defined MS progression, each with distinct strengths in usability, bias handling, and treatment modeling. These findings support future tool use in personalized risk stratification and secondary prevention.
Details
- Title
- Predicting disease progression in multiple sclerosis with clinically accessible information and technology
- Authors/Creators
- Tom A N Fuchs - Amsterdam NeuroscienceMenno M Schoonheim - Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamEva M M Strijbis - Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamJulia R Jelgerhuis - Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamDana Horakova - Charles UniversityEva K Havrdova - Charles UniversityTomas Uher - Charles UniversityRobert Zivadinov - Jacobs InstituteSerkan Ozakbas - İzmir University of EconomicsMarc Girard - Université de MontréalRaed Alroughani - Amiri HospitalPierre Grammond - Centre intégré de santé et de services sociaux de Chaudière-AppalachesAlessandra Lugaresi - University of BolognaValentina Tomassini - University of Chieti-PescaraTomas Kalincik - The Royal Melbourne HospitalIzanne Roos - The Royal Melbourne HospitalOliver Gerlach - Zuyderland Medisch CentrumAnneke van der Walt - The Alfred HospitalSamia J Khoury - American University of Beirut Medical CenterVincent van Pesch - Cliniques Universitaires Saint-LucAndrea Surcinelli - Ospedale "Santa Maria delle Croci" di RavennaMatteo Foschi - Ospedale "Santa Maria delle Croci" di RavennaMaria Jose Sa - Hospital de São JoãoEmanuelle D'amico - Medical and Surgical Sciences, Universita di Foggia, Foggia, ItalyJens Kuhle - University Hospital of BaselElisabetta Cartechini - University of MacerataDavide Maimone - Ospedale CannizzaroRana Karabudak - Yeditepe UniversityAysun Soysal - Bakırköy Psychiatric HospitalDaniele Spitaleri - Azienda Ospedaliera S.Giuseppe MoscatiGuy Laureys - Ghent University HospitalBruce Taylor - Royal Hobart HospitalMarie D'hooghe - ms consultants, inc.Radek Ampapa - Hospital JihlavaTamara Castillo-Triviño - Biogipuzkoa Health Research InstituteAyse Altintas - Koç UniversityOrla Gray - South Eastern Health and Social Care TrustRiadh Gouider - Razi UniversityJose E Meca-Lallana - Hospital Universitario Virgen de la ArrixacaAllan G Kermode - The University of Western AustraliaMarzena Fabis-Pedrini - Perron Institute for Neurological and Translational ScienceWilliam M Carroll - The University of Western AustraliaKoen de Gans - Groene Hart ZiekenhuisJose Luis Sanchez-Menoyo - Hospital de GaldakaoMasoud Etemadifar - Danesh-e-Tandorosti Iranian Institute of Higher HealthAbdullah Al-Asmi - Sultan Qaboos UniversityPamela McCombe - Royal Brisbane and Women's HospitalMihaela Simu - Victor Babeș University of Medicine and Pharmacy TimișoaraMehmet Fatih Yetkin - Erciyes UniversityTalal Al-Harbi - King Fahad Specialist HospitalTunde Csepany - University of DebrecenPatrice Lalive - University Hospital of GenevaTodd A Hardy - Concord Repatriation General HospitalSudarshini Ramanathan - Concord Repatriation General HospitalBarbara Willekens - Antwerp University HospitalAngel Perez Sempere - Hospital General Universitario de Alicante Doctor BalmisSimón Cárdenas-Robledo - Hospital Universitario Nacional de ColombiaMario Habek - University Hospital Centre ZagrebBhim Singhal - Bombay HospitalNikolaos Grigoriadis - AHEPA University HospitalMagdolna Simo - Semmelweis UniversityVahid Shaygannejad - Isfahan University of Medical SciencesYolanda Blanco - Hospital Clínic de BarcelonaEduardo Aguera-Morales - University of CórdobaJustin Garber - Westmead HospitalClaudio Solaro - Ente Ospedaliero Ospedali GallieraNeil Shuey - St Vincent's Hospital MelbourneDheeraj Khurana - Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and ResearchDanny Decoo - Alrijne ZiekenhuisAbdorreza Naser Moghadasi - Tehran University of Medical SciencesKatherine Buzzard - Box Hill HospitalOlga Skibina - Box Hill HospitalNevin John - Monash UniversityThor Petersen - Aarhus University HospitalBianca Weinstock-Guttman - Jacobs Institute
- Publication Details
- Journal of neurology, Vol.273(5), 281
- Publisher
- SPRINGER HEIDELBERG
- Number of pages
- 18
- Identifiers
- 991005877697907891
- Copyright
- © The Author(s) 2026
- Murdoch Affiliation
- Institute for Immunology and Infectious Diseases
- Language
- English
- Resource Type
- Journal article
UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
This output has contributed to the advancement of the following goals:
Source: SDGs in the Output
Metrics
1 Record Views