Logo image
The appraisal of policy appraisal – Learning about the quality of impact assessment
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

The appraisal of policy appraisal – Learning about the quality of impact assessment

C.A. Dunlop, O. Fritsch and C.M. Radaelli
Revue française d'administration publique, Vol.149(1), pp.163-178
2014
pdf
policy appraisal.pdfDownloadView
Author’s Version Open Access
url
Link to Published Version *Subscription may be requiredView

Abstract

What do governments, international organizations and stakeholders mean when they say that proposals for new regulation should be systematically appraised? And do regulators really use the results of appraisal? In this article, we consider two dimensions of policy appraisal: the breadth and scope of the empirical analysis, and the utilization of impact assessment. We use these two dimensions to produce an explanatory typology with four types. The types enable us to review the literature systematically, exposing gaps as well as documenting the results. In the final part of the article we build hypotheses that link quality of analysis and utilization, thus showing how future research may become less descriptive and more inclined to test explicit hypotheses.

Details

Metrics

74 File views/ downloads
45 Record Views
Logo image