Journal article
The problem of simplification: Think-tanks, recipes, equity and ‘Turning around low-performing schools’
The Australian Educational Researcher, Vol.43(1), pp.111-129
2016
Abstract
Non-government actors such as think-tanks are playing an important role in Australian policy work. As governments increasingly outsource policy work previously done by education departments and academics to these new policy actors, more think-tanks have emerged that represent a wide range of political views and ideological positions. This paper looks at the emergence of the Grattan Institute as one significant player in Australian education policy with a particular emphasis on Grattan’s report ‘Turning around low-performing schools’. Grattan exemplifies many of the facets of Barber’s ‘deliverology’, as they produce reports designed to be easily digested, simply actioned and provide reassurance that there is an answer, often through focusing on ‘what works’ recipes. ‘Turning around low-performing schools’ is a perfect example of this deliverology. However, a close analysis of the Report suggests that it contains four major problems which seriously impact its usefulness for schools and policymakers: it ignores data that may be more important in explaining the turn-around of schools, the Report is overly reliant on NAPLAN data, there are reasons to be suspicious about the evidence assembled, and finally the Report falls into a classic trap of logic—the post hoc fallacy.
Details
- Title
- The problem of simplification: Think-tanks, recipes, equity and ‘Turning around low-performing schools’
- Authors/Creators
- T. Loughland (Author/Creator) - The University of SydneyG. Thompson (Author/Creator) - Murdoch University
- Publication Details
- The Australian Educational Researcher, Vol.43(1), pp.111-129
- Publisher
- Springer Verlag
- Identifiers
- 991005542051807891
- Murdoch Affiliation
- School of Education
- Language
- English
- Resource Type
- Journal article
UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
This output has contributed to the advancement of the following goals:
Metrics
260 File views/ downloads
136 Record Views
InCites Highlights
These are selected metrics from InCites Benchmarking & Analytics tool, related to this output
- Collaboration types
- Domestic collaboration
- Citation topics
- 6 Social Sciences
- 6.11 Education & Educational Research
- 6.11.345 Educational Reform
- Web Of Science research areas
- Education & Educational Research
- ESI research areas
- Social Sciences, general