Abstract
Luck (2024) argues that being “rightly dominated” by a benevolent super-intelligent AI (super-AI) that would optimise our freedom by allowing as much as we need but not more, may be a good thing and provides analogies between God and super-AI playing this role. Our view is that such an approach is highly problematic if we have a grasp of how super-AI works (we will call this option one) and even more problematic if we don’t (option two)...
